Preparing an Executive Peer Discussion
CTN AON field guide
A practical planning tool for marketing and program leaders
Use buyer input to choose the topic
CIO Talk Network’s executive conversations help CTN AON understand the questions leaders face. We use focused polls and direct conversations with network members and relevant peers to understand current issues, test topics and plan programs.
For your program, record who contributed, when and what changed in the question. Keep the limits of that input alongside any conclusions, and let differing views change the focus.
Before, during and after
Before: Define the decision
- Test the question with relevant buyer and peer input.
- Choose and prepare contributors.
- Agree what to produce and how the conversation may be used.
What you will prepare: A brief with the buyer question; a description of the people to invite; a guide for the moderator.
During: Explore the trade-offs
- Ask about real decisions and examples.
- Give people room to speak and compare their roles and situations.
- Capture differences and unresolved questions.
What you will prepare: Discussion notes; the choices people faced and where they disagreed; open questions.
After: Give participants something they can use
- Separate what people said from your view of what it means.
- Send a short report of what the group learned and the questions still open.
- Keep the original question and background with any request for a next step.
What you will prepare: A short discussion report; requested next steps; the next question to test.
Use the questions raised in the discussion to plan what to do next.
Before: Build a question worth discussing
Use these six questions with your program team. The downloadable PDF includes a page you can print and complete.
1. Decision and why now
What is the audience trying to decide? Why does it matter now?
2. People and situations
Whose role, experience or situation makes this question relevant?
3. Question to test
Write one question that invites practical experience and differing views.
4. Input that could change the topic
What could buyers or peers tell you that would make you change the question?
5. Perspectives to bring together
Which different roles, situations and experiences should be in the room?
6. Useful takeaway
What should participants be able to carry into their next team conversation?
Check before inviting
- The question has been tested with relevant input; its limits are recorded.
- The team knows why each person belongs in the discussion and how to prepare them.
- The moderator and sponsor understand their roles in helping peers compare experience.
- Guests know what may be shared, whose names may be used and what follow-up to expect.
- The team has agreed what to send afterward, who prepares it and when it is due.
Record the program owner, discussion date and date for sharing the report.
During: Help peers compare real decisions
Use these four prompts to guide the discussion. Follow the examples and differences that matter to the room.
Start with the decision
What are you trying to decide, and what is holding it up?
Ask what is at stake, what has already been tried and who needs to act.
Ask for a concrete example
Walk us through a recent example. What happened, and what made the decision difficult?
Separate direct experience from predictions or secondhand views.
Explore contrasting experience
Who sees this differently? Which parts of your situation change the answer?
Invite missing perspectives and examine the trade-offs behind different choices.
Choose a useful next question
What question will you take back to your team, and what remains unresolved?
Name the evidence or perspective still needed for the next decision.
Keep the discussion useful
Invite quieter people to share their experience. Keep long answers on track and ask for specific examples. Bring promotional remarks back to the decision being discussed. Describe disagreements accurately rather than forcing agreement.
A simple note-taking structure
Example + context
What happened, and under which conditions?
Difference or trade-off
Where did people disagree or make different choices, and why?
Open question
What still needs evidence or another perspective?
After: Send a report peers can use
Before the discussion, agree what the short report should help people do. The report explains what the group learned, where people differed and which questions remain. Write it from the actual conversation and keep those limits clear.
- Decision context: State the question, audience and the situations that affect the decision.
- What was heard: Record actual examples and different views. Use names only as agreed.
- Interpretation: Explain how you reached your conclusions from the discussion and what those conclusions cannot tell you.
- Open questions: Name what remains unknown and the evidence that could help.
- Next use: Give readers questions for their team, help with a decision or another item agreed in the brief.
- Follow-through: Keep the question and background with each request for another conversation. Name who will respond and when.
Illustrative fictional example
Using AI in customer service
This shows a planning structure, not collected research or a client result.
An imagined company is considering using AI to handle more customer service requests.
Question to test: Before we use AI more widely, who will handle requests it cannot resolve?
If relevant peers identify cost or data quality as the immediate obstacle, change the question you plan to explore.
Questions for the discussion report
Decisions for the system and for people
Which requests can AI handle, and which need a person?
Ownership
Who handles a request AI cannot resolve, and when should another team help?
Next evidence check
What would we need to check before using AI for more requests?
Want help preparing a peer discussion?
Tell us who you want to bring together and the question you want them to explore. Let us know where you need help with the discussion.
Share this resource
